Wall Street Pizza & Restaurant

Reviews

• Amy G.

  star star star star star 10 August 2026

  My boyfriend got a cheese pizza. He loved it!
  I got a garden salad, add grilled chicken and black olives and onions. Super yummy. A little disappointed they didn't cut the chicken into bite size pizza. They also forgot my dressing, but hey, we are all human.
  
  Update, we've gotten from here three more times since, and it's been amazing!

• Claire L.

  star star star star_border star_border 9 August 2026

  Wall Street Pizza is a decent pizza spot in downtown New Haven. My boyfriend and I came in a weekday, later afternoon, to enjoy their Happy hour specials (50% of a large pizza). We chose sausage as our topping.
  
  While the pizza was certainly edible, there was nothing very compelling about it, and the cheese was almost glistening. The pizza was so greasy that I had to use a napkin to dab some grease off before eating a slice.
  Also, this was a personal preference, but I didn't like the sausage much either; it tasted extremely salty but there was no distinctive porky flavor. If you had told me this was chicken or beef I wouldn't have known otherwise. The crust was incredibly thin, which I guess is a New Haven tradition but I personally am not a big fan of thin-crust pizzas. There were some areas where the crust was so thin it was blackened and charred. The pizza itself had very little structural integrity (flimsy), and the cheese slid off the pizza in large globs.
  
  However, Wall Street Pizza does provide complimentary ranch and buffalo hot sauce, which makes the pizza much, much more enjoyable. The pizza is large enough to split between 3-4 people. Furthermore, it was quite fresh and piping hot when we first bit into it. I would recommend coming here during their happy hours for half-priced pizzas, which I think last until 6 pm on weekdays.

• Deborah D.

  star star star star star_border 4 August 2026

  A reliable family run place to have a quick meal.  
  The pizza crust is thin and cooked perfectly.  I enjoy the casual atmosphere and the softly played music. Overall I would recommend the food.  It is a nice place to stop for a quick bite to eat when we are in town.

• Jonathan C.

  star star star star_border star_border 29 July 2026

  Ordered a pizza slice and wings for delivery. The pizza slice had a crispy thin crust, and was just a tad oily. The wings had nice spicy sauce but I felt were a little soggy, maybe because of the time between their preparation and arrival.

• Jan B.

  star star star star_border star_border 13 July 2026

  I was attending a show at Yale and I hadn't eaten dinner .. my daughter pointed me down the street from her school to Wall Street pizza and she said "that's where everyone goes" .. I ran down the street to grab a slice of pizza and something to drink. I walked in and was greeted by a woman behind the counter .. I asked do you sell slices? She points to two trays each with two slices on them one was bacon onion and broccoli and the other was sausage (I think) she said we also have plain cheese if you want. I ordered a slice of the bacon w/onion and broccoli and a coke from the fountain. The pizza was ok .. not what I was expecting. The crust was thin just how I like it but there did not seem to be enough sauce just not a lot of flavor. The big issue was actually the soda, it was suppose to be a Coca Cola and tasted way off. I am not sure what was wrong with it but I considered bringing it back up to the counter but just decided it wasn't worth an argument. Not the best pizza in New Haven for sure.